ICU Bed Capacity Varies Widely Nationwide

Mar 25, 2020
Originally published on March 26, 2020 1:47 pm

As the COVID-19 pandemic intensifies, some communities will be better equipped to treat the sickest patients — specifically those requiring admission to intensive care units — than others. Not only do ICU capabilities vary from hospital to hospital, but also some parts of the country have far more critical care beds by population than others.

An NPR analysis of data from the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice looked at how the nation's 100,000 ICU beds are distributed across the more than 300 markets that make up the country's hospital system.

NPR found that ICU bed capacity varies widely across the United States. ICU beds are especially important now because they are the hospital units typically equipped to treat patients with respiratory problems that require ventilators.

"The implications from this data is that the pandemic will look quite different in different places," says Eric Toner, a physician and a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

"Some places will maybe be able to get by without having to ration critical care. Other places definitely will not be able to," he says. "The worst-case scenario would be catastrophic failure of health care in that facility."

A report from the Society of Critical Care Medicine found that more than nine out of 10 intensive care beds nationally are in metropolitan areas with a population of more than 50,000. Only 1 percent of America's ICU beds are in rural areas.

David Wallace, a researcher and critical care doctor at the University of Pittsburgh, found that larger hospitals, teaching hospitals and those whose ICUs were at high occupancy were more likely to have added ICU beds from 1997 to 2011.

Toner says those disparities will expose regional differences in access to critical health care in a pandemic.

"We are seeing the fruits of trying to have a market solution to a national strategic issue," he says. "We have the number of beds we do because that's what the market is or demands where."

Craig Coopersmith, who leads the Emory Critical Care Center in Atlanta, calls the pandemic a "once-in-a-lifetime event."

"One can't develop a health care system solely for times of pandemic," he says. "If they did, the vast majority of times ICU beds would be empty."

And, he says, there is "absolutely no standard," for critical care beds nationally.

Still, whether it's better to be a COVID-19 patient in a big city or a smaller one will depend on how many people are infected in those areas and on the local hospital's capabilities.

Wallace says even his own research into counting ICU beds is an oversimplification because intensive care units themselves vary so widely.

"While I may be able to count the number of beds in Region A and Region B and the underlying populations in those two areas," he says, "what those beds and ICUs are actually able to provide is an entirely different question."

Both Wallace and Toner tell NPR that hospitals will try to manage high demand for critical care beds by repurposing some of their facilities, shifting staff and moving patients between hospitals. Toner argues the country should collectively share that cost.

"It's in the national interest to have hospitals and intensive care capacity in places that are not profitable," he says.

Correction: 3/25/20

A previous version of this story included a searchable database of ICU beds in hospital markets across the country. Due to a calculation error, the database underestimated the number of beds in some markets. Those markets included Nashville and Las Vegas regions that were cited in the story.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Intensive care units have become crucial during the coronavirus pandemic because ICUs are where patients who need ventilators are treated. As NPR's Robert Benincasa reports, ICU capabilities vary from hospital to hospital, and some parts of the country have many more beds by population than others.

ROBERT BENINCASA, BYLINE: An NPR analysis of data from the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice looked at how the country's nearly 100,000 ICU beds are distributed. The analysis spanned the nation's 300 regional hospital markets. In some areas, like several in Florida, there are more than 60 intensive care beds for every 100,000 residents. In others, such as Las Vegas and Nashville, there are fewer than 20. A recent report from the Society of Critical Care Medicine found that more than 9 out of 10 intensive care beds nationally are in metropolitan areas. Only 1% are in rural areas.

ERIC TONER: The pandemic will look quite different in different places (ph).

BENINCASA: Eric Toner is a physician and senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

TONER: Some places will maybe be able to get by without having to ration critical care. Other places definitely will not be able to get by.

BENINCASA: Craig Coopersmith, who leads the Emory Critical Care Center in Atlanta, says there's no benchmark for the optimal number of ICU beds. Individual hospitals determine what they can offer and what their local markets demand, and the prospect of a pandemic isn't the main driver.

CRAIG COOPERSMITH: One can't develop a health care system solely for times a pandemic because if they did, the vast majority of times, one's ICU beds would be empty.

BENINCASA: David Wallace, a researcher and critical care doctor at the University of Pittsburgh, found that larger hospitals teaching hospitals and those whose ICUs were at high occupancy have been more likely to add ICU beds in the past. Those and other factors will matter when it comes to dealing with the pandemic. But, he says, even his own research counting ICU beds is an oversimplification.

DAVID WALLACE: While I may be able to count the number of beds in region A and region B and the underlying populations in those two areas, what those beds and what those ICUs are actually able to provide is an entirely different question.

BENINCASA: Toner says the pandemic may demonstrate that a market-based approach to allocating hospital resources doesn't work, and he advocated shifting some responsibility to taxpayers.

TONER: We need to fund hospitals in locations that can't support themselves on their own because it's in the national interest to have hospitals and critical care capacity in places that are not profitable.

BENINCASA: For now, though, critical care doctors say hospitals will cope with an influx of COVID-19 patients by repurposing some facilities, shifting staff and moving patients between hospitals as long as that remains possible.

Robert Benincasa, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.